Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label climate change. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 4, 2015

Three Blind Mice I : Krugman, Romm and Roberts Run the Wheel Round and Round

Dave Roberts, of Grist fame, recently wrote a piece disputing that we can know whether transitioning to a “clean” economy cheaply and easily is possible, calling out Krugman (economist aka voodoo practitioner) and Romm (stuffed shirt writer dude) for essentially saying how cheap and easy it would be.

Surely one of the three must be right, or closer to the truth, right? Sure. Dave, you win the Glaucoma Prize for being the Not-Quite-Blind Mouse! But I still hear that wheel spinning. Hmmm… what have we here? We have three VIP dudes talking climate. Why am I not ecstatic? You see, it’s kind of like...

three guys with an STD discussing the merits of prostitution and how to improve it so they can keep getting their STDs. (Let’s say Dave is merely “at risk” for fairness’ sake.)

You see, you can’t “fix” prostitution. It will always exist. There will always be at least a small number that actually choose to do it, but most will be some degree of forced, coerced or desperate. And the Johns and Johnettes, well... People really, really, really like sex and really, really, really like money. And economics is the same. Sex sells. When was the last time you saw an ad that told you something truly useful about a product instead of a guy or gal draped all over it half naked? It's the wheel I hear whirring, whirring, whirring. I hope you will, too, in time.

Just as prostitution cannot, will not, be ended because we wish it, and cannot, will not ever be healthy for the vast majority, economics is the same. Economics cannot be fixed because the flaws that it is based on are inherent. Money, power, desperation, force, greed, desire, all feed economic thought and, especially, economic actions. But it gets worse. While prostitution may exist because of the same basic drives, wants and needs, in many healthy communities where needs are met, there often is no prostitution, even if it is more because of social pressure than anything else. That is, I am contradicting myself: We can have communities without prostitution. That’s a step up from economics: It is impossible for neo-classical economics to produce a sustainable society. Besides, prostitution fills a basic drive. Economics creates the illusion of doing so. Better a prostitute than an economist, if you ask me. Far more honest a profession.


Oh, no I di’int! Oh, yes I did! I just went there. You need to, too, ‘cause if you don’t, we’re all pretty well screwed. (It's OK, you can smile. It was unintentional.)

Economics exists to perpetuate a process of wealth creation and accretion, and nothing more. Oh, sure, you have a pure scientist or two, but read the stuff! It's crackpot! Here's the biggest lie: Current economic thinking can define and guide the creation of sustainable systems.

Because elephants beget mices.


No, the principles of current economics cannot create a sustainable system when they have zero principles of sustainable systems within their number. Elephants to do not beget roses. Never will. For example, endless substitution. Economics never even addresses that there absolutely must be a final substitution beyond which all stops. Sustainable design begins with, so, how much shit we got? What can be done with it? How can we help it make more, faster, while recreating itself endlessly?

These two things are not the same. Elephants don't beget mices.


Economics, it turns out, isn’t based on science, but on philosophy. It uses lots of numbers, sure, and we all know *math* is science, so economics must be, too, right? Sure, so long as you accept that because a soap box derby racer has wheels and a steering wheel it’s a viable commuter vehicle. No, putting on the clothes of respectable science doesn’t make economics a science. What matters are the underlying assumptions. Economics is actually based on human behavior. Markets are not machines, they are aggregations of people. Economics is assumptions about what people do and why. What economics doesn’t do is consider the physical world. Economics must be based in resources to be a viable basis for understanding our world or it’s just a variant of psychology/sociology. But economics isn’t. While there are economists espousing this essential position, even there they do not begin and end with ecology, they merely include it. At least these mice aren’t blind! Merely myopic! And hanging out in the Red Light District of economic fallacy and fantasy.

All the while that wheel keeps spinning, spinning, spinning, but going nowhere. In his piece, Sir Grist writes the following graph,
Take, for instance, Paul Krugman, who crows, in a column called “Salvation Gets Cheap,” that “even under the most ambitious goals the [IPCC] assessment considers, the estimated reduction in economic growth would basically amount to a rounding error, around 0.06 percent per year.” Joe Romm touts the same number in “Climate Panel Stunner: Avoiding Climate Catastrophe Is Super Cheap — But Only If We Act Now.
then fires this shot across their respective bows:
…the idea that aggressive climate mitigation is going to shave precisely 0.06 percent off GDP growth is utterly fantastical.

For one thing, as I’ve said before, the economic models from which IPCC and others draw these numbers are just this side of wild guesses, based on assumptions about economic growth, resource prices, and technological development decades in the future.
Dave d’Grist (I tease, but I like Dave’s work… but like popping him upside his head, too, for not understanding the subject fully) is correct when he says models are guesses. Duh. Any forward-looking discussion is. But his real point is that Blinder Mice 1 and 2 put a huge amount of faith in things that are 1. based on abstractions, 2. are guesses, and 3. have zero connection to the true underlying issue: Resources and their consumption. Actually, #3 is my point. Dave is guilty of this, also. Note he doesn't say they should not do this or economics should not be trusted, he says the models are too unreliable to justify the other two mice trusting them so much. And Dave fails on #3 as badly as the other two.

Economics, once it bothers to consider the real world at all, dismisses it with a concept that does not work in your home or mine: Endless substitution. Yup, they just erase the issue of  resources from the ledger. So, the *basis* of every productive and consumptive act we engage in is completely dismissed as even mattering. Let’s try this endless substitution thingy, though.

I’m out of steak, but there’s hamburger. So far, so good. Except in economics your $5 steak is equal to your $1 hamburger. Home, not restaurant! Try that with your check book! Still, I guess since we ate, it’s OK. Ah, but eventually the hamburger goes, too. Ah, tofu! Tofu steakburger! Dang! Now we ran out of tofu! Err… OK, we can make a heavy biscuit shaped like a steak and smother it in meatless gravy! Yay!

See where this is going? Such people believe this crap!

And even The Grister accepts this insanity. But we need to clarify the insanity. So far all we know is economics ignore resources because they think steak is tofu. Corollary might be oil equals bio-fuels. Same problem. Oil has far more energy than bio-fuels and is far more fungible. Currently, takes around 1 barrel of oil to get ten out of the ground. Tar sands? Maybe 1 barrel to get 3, which is below the estimated rate to maintain our current economic model. Oops.

Oil is used in some form or degree in 95% of everything we produce. Go ahead. Look around. Now imagine either not having 95% of everything, or finding substitutes for some portion of 95% of everything. Now go get a broom and dustpan and pick your brain up off the floor. Five second rule if you want to apply endless substitution and recycle it.

Endless substitution is bull. Thus, the fact the planet is *finite* can no longer be ignored. Ipso facto, that every *economic* decision, and every decision, period, is an ecological decision also can no longer be ignored. Pause with me as we watch that wheel come to a stop and our Three Blind Mice sweep up what’s left of their brains.

Poor mices.

We are now ready to understand what has just happened. Rather than sitting on our brains and pretending that the crap we make up in those ego-inflated brains is more important than the real world from which literally everything around us comes, we must now accept that every discussion of Climate Change starts not with economics, but Ecology. (Our mice may never recover.) Logically, economics exists only as a subset of Ecology, not as a (voodoo) science above and beyond the ecology.

There are people who understand this. In the ‘70’s Mollison and Holmgren suggested designing our human systems based on ecological systems made some degree of sense. More prosaically, the Limits to Growth study, and its update a few years back, set out a set of possible scenarios, the worst of which we are tracking perfectly thus far. They looked at pollution, population, resource consumption, etc., and concluded we’d have used too much of many things and begin destabilizing. That scenario leads to collapse of our current system around mid-century. I don’t mean an economic slowdown, I mean society falling apart. And there are more. Many more. BTW, the Limits to Growth study didn't include Climate Change, so things are that much worse than seemed then.

But let’s back up a bit. Why the frack is Climate Change being discussed separately from resources if every decision is ultimately an ecological decision? Good galdarned question. Part of it we’ve already discussed: Economics can fix every shortage, which we know to be hubris, at best. The extension of understanding this is false is that it must also mean we *will* run out of things. Worse, we can use even truly, naturally renewable things up so fast that we either destroy the source or they cannot possibly meet our collective needs.

Water, anyone? Planet’s 70% water, yet water shortages all over the globe because we either are using it too fast (declining aquifers, river flows, lakes, reservoirs) or have poisoned it with things like fossil fuels-derived pollutants, er, fertilizers. Water is endlessly recyclable, and it's all over the planet! But we have used the *available* potable water so quickly we are drying aquifers and poisoning systems far faster than nature can replenish them. So we have built purification plants of various kinds. And the situation continues to rapidly worsen.

If we can't keep endless water flowing at rates we can survive on... ummm...

But none of that is THE point. THE point is this: Climate Change is the result of over-consumption of resources. Sure, you understand there’s too much CO2. Sure you understand efficiency can reduce this. Sure you think you can conserve energy. But I didn’t say misuse of fossil fuels, I said misuse of resources. Plural. Peak Oil is perhaps one you’ve heard of, but there is a long list of non-renewable resources also at, near, or past peak. Phosphorus, the P in every farmer’s and gardener’s NPK, is expected to run out around the end of this century. Not peak, but be *all used up.* When we are expected to have 2 – 5 billion more people on the planet. 12 billion people with no phosphorus? We could crash back to prehistoric numbers. 

All because economists think steaks are tofu.

Don't despair, though! We can farm regeneratively and actually build soil instead of depleting it, and phosphorus. But we aren't. Well, most aren't. This is one of the few areas where everyday peeps are listening and asking for organic foods. What you peeps haven't quite figured out yet is that gardening/farming will need to become a daily part of most people's lives because regenerative farming/gardening mot only can sequester carbon and helps create a localized economy (more on this some other time), keeps chemicals like phosphorous and nitrogen from killing our oceans when they run off into them, but preserves resources, or more accurately keeps them stored for later, better use - and keeps them from being used now..... which is less consumption.... which is less growth.... which is less carbon... which is.... moving toward simplicity.

The times they are a' changin'... Why aren't we changing faster, fast enough? 1. You haven't figured out yet just how much the times are a' gonna change, 2. you love your stuff, and are far too comfortable, 3. ask Monsanto, 4. ask the Big Oil and their congressional call boys and girls, and... and... and...

Mostly, you just don't believe it can all go to hell. But it can, it is, it will.


Oh, and “renewable” energy, all those windmills and stuff we are supposed to transition to according to our Three Blind Mice? Rare Earth metals are also a limited resource. Very limited.

Thought experiment: 9 – 12 billion people at, say, European living standards. This would actually mean massively increased consumption for around 5.5 billion people, plus all the new ones still to come. We are already using resources at a rate sustainable only with 1.5 Earths. We’d need 5 Earths or so to have 9 billion or more live like Europeans, and they use 50% of the energy we Americans use.

So…. say we transition to renewables at current consumption (read: lifestyle) rates. Then multiply by 3x, minimum, so it’s fair for all. Wonderful. Happy yeast! (More yeast in a moment.) Now, replace all that infrastructure every thirty to fifty years, forever. Yes, forever. What? You think that substitution crap kicks back in for some unknown future generation? Sorry, no. Tech? Same resource problem. Perhaps it extends some stuff a bit, but it's irrelevant given we are already over-consuming.

We have a problem! Mouse brains clean-up, aisle three! Yeast spillage, aisle four!

About those yeast…

Why else? We discount the future. We have a very difficult time, collectively, giving much of a damn about future generations. On top of this there is "Holy Technology, Batman. Tech will save us!" Except it hasn't. We work as hard, for less, as we did in 1970. Actually we work more: Women are far more involved in working outside the home now. Real wages for you and me? Up 4%, total, since 1970. Total. But our productivity is significantly higher. Thanks, bosses!!! We work ever harder, create more for you and you give us Absolutely Nothing.

Why else? We are Beyond History. Growth (substitution, tech) can and will go on forever simply because it has for so long. It's a lie. We have recessions and depressions. But, yes, since the end of the Middle Ages, say 1200 AD, it's been an overall upward trend. 900 years of growth! Gosh, must be permanent!

Not so much. Any number of more isolated civilizations have risen and fallen over that same time, always with resource and/or climate issues. And many rose and fell before that, too. History is littered with fallen civilizations. And they virtually always try to get over their problems with more, more, more. Then they have nothing. Then they die.

But mostly, we just can't conceive of failure. We can't imagine actually being human. We put people on the moon, for goodness' sake. We own Nature, physics be damned. And, give up my lifestyle? It's my RIGHT as an American!!!!

Except, no.

Dr Al Bartlett thinks you and I might be dummer than yeest. So far, he’s right. Imagine a jar. The world is the sugar in the jar. We are the yeast. Assume there is enough sugar for one hour.It's 11:00. At what time have the yeast eaten half the food? 1 minute before 12? Twelve? 12:01? 12:37? Hmmm? Bet you guessed 12:30. Half the time, half the food.

Nope. Organisms grow to fill the food supply. This is why all natural systems see a saw-toothed population chart. A few too many, they eat too much, some die. A smaller population eats less, the food supply recovers, they balance for a while, then there are too many eaters, food supply falls, eaters die. In a closed system, eventually everything dies as the food is completely consumed. (I’m sure you’ve flushed a forgotten goldfish or two.)

It’s a question of exponents. Any constant rate of growth, or average rate of growth, is exponential. Let’s take that old shampoo commercial, tell two friends who tell two friends who tell two friends, etc. 1 x 2 = 4 > 8 > 16 > 32 > 64 > 128 > 256 > 512 > 1,024 >2,048 > 4,096 > 8,192 > 16,384 > 32,768 > 65,356 > 131,072 > 262,144 > 524,288 >  1,048,576... How many of you have even 16 true friends? After 21 days... Food supplies are similarly limited when doubling is occurring.

The yeast double like this. Notice every doubling is GREATER than all that came before, being more than half of all that’s been consumed ever. For simplicity, let’s say it’s exactly double. Working backwards from 12:00 o’clock, what time do we have half the sugar left, my fellow yeast?

Yup, 11:59. 11-flippin-50-fricken-9. But we have an hour to prepare!

DO we? OK, what time do we still have ¾ of the sugar? 11:58. 7/8? 11:57. 15/16? 11:56. Four minutes before The End of All Yeast, it looks like we have food forever. No wonder our Three Blind Mice think it’s all about economics instead of resources. No wonder you, my little yeasties, think resources will go on forever.

The truth is, we humans have been doubling consumption and population very, very quickly.
worldpopgr.gif
Make that timeline equal to one hour and you see what I mean. Charts of resource consumption take the same shape.

“The greatest shortcoming of the human race is our inability to understand the exponential function.”
― Albert A. Bartlett
(This whole bit was lifted from Dr. Al.)

Sorry for burying the lede. (I’m lying.) This simple little observation explains why we have used half the world’s recoverable oil, have water shortages globally and will be out of phosphorus by the end of this century. And it’s why we have Climate Change.

In case you missed it, we appear to be sitting at less than one minute before 12:00. Enjoy your meal.

If we had understood our resource base from the beginning, or even 30 years ago, collectively, we would have acted very differently. Of course that assumes we aren’t collectively sui-genocidal, of which I am not yet convinced. Instead, we pumped huge amounts of oil, gas and coal into the air as CO2 and methane (natural gas) thinking they were inexhaustible. Had we thought them exhaustible and thought, gee, if we’ve been around 200,000 years or so and want to still be around in 200,000 years or so, maybe, just maybe, we should slow this little mouse wheel down and do some careful planning, things would be different. Of course, we also thought we couldn't alter the atmosphere so much as to threaten our own survival. (Scientists have known this for more than a hundred years.)

Atmospheric CO2 was only around 315 or 320 ppm in 1950. Population was 2.5 billion in 1950. It’s 7.1 billion today. C02 is 400 ppm. This is not coincidental, it is causal. We had 1 billion in 1804. ONE. C02 was around 280 ppm, which was normal for a warm interglacial period. In 3 million years and around 30 or so glacial/interglacial cycles it never went above about 300 ppm.

CH4 (methane/natural gas) is even worse, up nearly 300%!!!

By 1950 we were at 2.5 billion and CO2 was 315. Today we have 7.1 billion and CO2 is 400. You couldn’t make two curves more similar if you tried.

This begs the question, if Climate Change is caused by resource misuse, isn’t the solution resources wisely allocated? How do we keep consuming and expect to stop Climate Change? Efficiency? Nope. We are massively, massively more efficient than in 1800 or 1850, yet resource consumption continues to rise. In fact, we are more efficient year after year, decade after decade, yet consumption keeps rising.

Population trumps efficiency.

What about stabilizing population? Too late. Remember: 1. Already using at the rate of 1.5 Earths, and most of the planet still lives with less than the poorest of American poor. Five Earths for all of us to live like Europeans. Even more to live like Americans. 2. Fossil Fuels are not the only limited resources. Phosphorus and Rare Earth metals, both vital to the “green” revolution won’t survive this century. And there are hundreds of other similar points I could raise.

Still think Climate Change is about economics? It's like saying planetary physics is about astrology. But let's not argue by analogy. Ecology as the basis of all decision-making is not so trivial. It's First Principles thinking, which is where the best problem solving begins. Elon Musk, to engage in an appeal to authority fallacy, recently said,  
I think it’s important to reason from first principles rather than by analogy. The normal way we conduct our lives is we reason by analogy. We are doing this because it’s like something else that was done, or it is like what other people are doing. Slight iterations on a theme.
“First principles” is a physics way of looking at the world. What that really means is that you boil things down to the most fundamental truths and then reason up from there. That takes a lot more mental energy.
Notice Elon didn't start with economics or how it's always been done? He started with, what the frack is a battery and how the frack can we do it better? So, if our planet is dying by our hand, if everything we have has come from that planet, what *must* be the first consideration in every decision we make, period?

The planet. And not what we *want* from it, but what we *need* from it. And, hold on to your brains, before that we have to ask, what *can* the planet provide? That's a First Principle question. We don't look at historical production and extrapolate, we look at what exists in a space. That is our starting point, whether a balcony flower box or a farm or a bio-region. We need to know what is there first. This includes wind, sun, rain. I's called a resource inventory. (It will include human resources (How many people? What are their skills? Their limitations? etc.?) further steps down the line.)

This is what Mollison and Holmgren realized back in the '70's by merely observing. They teased out of the natural systems they observed underlying principles by which natural systems were organized, then listed them as ways for us to apply the same principles to our human systems. They also proposed a process to apply them that started with what Musk would do decades later: Look. Literally observe, but also look differently. What are the resources in this space? The energy? Let's quantify those first so we know what this space *can* do, *can* provide. Only after they asked what the Earth could do in any given space did they suggest asking what they need from it. Only then did they then say we could seek ways to harmonize the two.

Notice there is no discussion of wants? First things first. First Principles first. Body temp, food, water. Cover those first. Anything else is gravy.

But, by applying natural principles to human/natural systems they found they could speed up Nature's ways. Nature + Big Brained Non-Idiot Humans = More. This is not achieved by appropriating Nature, damaging Nature, but by using Nature's own processes to do what nature does faster, more productively. Nature builds soil very, very slowly as detritous, leaves, bird poop, etc., fall to the ground and are reduced. We can speed this up with mulching, composting, etc. Nature's ways, sped up.

As you hopefully were and/or are now aware, the opposite has been true for the entirety of modern human civilizations. We have sought to feed our wants for 10k years, and the result is we're flirting with extinction.

But, using natural to aid Nature, we can create abundance. Not profit, abundance. Not excess, abundance. And from abundance you can then choose to meet some wants so long as you do not fall back into the wants-first trap and start this craziness all over again.

How do we get from a crisis of over-consumption to meeting global needs and eventually abundance rather than excess? Perhaps you've already guessed. Nature's ways. Start with the resources available. Start with needs.

Simplicity.

Everybody, off that freaking wheel! Economics is a Dead Man Walking. As are we if we don't get off that wheel.

Saturday, June 27, 2009

Re: Strassel's Propaganda: The Climate Change Climate Change

Sorry, folks, but this crap just needed to be responded to and I no longer have the patience nor the respect for these people to even pretend at polite discussion. They lie, they lie and then they lie some more, so this was written quickly and is likely full of typos and poorly articulated. But, hey, they deserve no better than my worst.

The fruits of her poison pen can be found here, if you can stomach it.

Strassel,

Before we get into your bullshit, here's the REAL science, which you didn't mention because, well, you're a propagandist:

From the US gov't, much of it done while BuCheney were in office:
http://www.climatescience.gov/Library/sap/sap4-3/final-report/default.htm

Copenhagen Synthesis Report (Note to propagandist: REAL science inside. May make your head explode.):
http://www.pik-potsdam.de/news/press-releases/files/synthesis-report-web.pdf

And just to make it real simple-like for you:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/apr/14/global-warming-target-2c


http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/interactive/2009/apr/14/climate-change-experts-predictions

My god, are you just bought? Appeal to Authority: Inhofe's list.

Utter bullocks. Of course, you can hide behind this being an "opinion piece" and not an "article" so you can pretend Inhofe is not a bought-and-paid-for shill of Big Oil/Coal, etc., and accept his "list" as meaning something. Only one problem: It's bullshit. Very few climate scientists therein. And virtually none actually DOING or PUBLISHING any science. Just like you cowards: can't compete, so you JUST LIE.

Funny, but you equate seven hundred fools who ARE NOT doing science and many of whom were bought by EXXON, et al., over the two thousand plus climate scientists who did the science behind the IPCC IV report? Are you completely unbalanced? Do you need meds?

And you LIE about it! You present the final WRITERS of the report, 50 or so you say, vs. the 700 when all they did was WRITE UP the paper. That is how science is done! How the hell would 2,000+ people write a single report together? (Lying is bad. You will go to hell! Don't you know? Where does your Christianity get off to?)

http://www.thedailygreen.com/environmental-news/latest/inhofe-global-warming-deniers-47011101

Here's more to consider:

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/06/bubkes/langswitch_lang/pl


http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2006/12/inhofes-last-stand/langswitch_lang/in

I guess you dumbasses want your title back? To wit:
Most consistently wrong media outlet:
The Australian (runner-up the UK Daily Telegraph). Both comfortably beating out the perennial favorite, the Wall Street Journal - maybe things have really changed there?
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2008/12/2008-year-in-review/langswitch_lang/in

Or how about this pile of manure offered up by Inhofe via Moronic Morano?
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/01/warm-reception-to-antarctic-warming-story/langswitch_lang/in

Let's get to your "science," you criminal against humanity:
Earth is cooling. What a damned fool. ALL of the years in the last twelve have been among the warmest in millions of years. ALL OF THEM. Oh, I know you're using 1998 as your start line because THAT IS THE ONLY YEAR YOU CAN START WITH TO GET A TEN YEAR TREND THAT GOES DOWNWARD. (Actually, you aren't. You have never read ANY of the science. That is obvious. You're just the bought-and-paid-for mouthpiece of the far right willing to lie so your children, should you have any, can die for your ideology because your party affiliation is more important to you than your kids, your country, your G_d.) You're too stupid about science to know a ten year trend is WEATHER not CLIMATE. If you look back over the history of the planet you will see many, many short-term trends embedded in long term trends. Look back through the temp record since 1850 and you will see a number of ten year trends that go opposite of the long-term warming. Why? Natural variability. (Go ahead, look it up. You know you want to.)

As for the piece of shit "paper" you started your rant about? Here's what real scientists have to say about it:
"...First off the authors of the submission; Alan Carlin is an economist and John Davidson is an ex-member of the Carter administration Council of Environmental Quality. Neither are climate scientists. That's not necessarily a problem - perhaps they have mastered multiple fields? - but it is likely an indication that the analysis is not going to be very technical (and so it will prove). Curiously, while the authors work for the NCEE (National Center for Environmental Economics), part of the EPA, they appear to have rather closely collaborated with one Ken Gregory (his inline comments appear at multiple points in the draft). Ken Gregory if you don't know is a leading light of the Friends of Science - a astroturf anti-climate science lobbying group based in Alberta. Indeed, parts of the Carlin and Davidson report appear to be lifted directly from Ken's rambling magnum opus on the FoS site. However, despite this odd pedigree, the scientific points could still be valid.

Their main points are nicely summarised thus: a) the science is so rapidly evolving that IPCC (2007) and CCSP (2009) reports are already out of date, b) the globe is cooling!, c) the consensus on hurricane/global warming connections has moved from uncertain to ambiguous, d) Greenland is not losing mass, no sirree…, e) the recession will save us!, f) water vapour feedback is negative!, and g) Scafetta and West's statistical fit of temperature to an obsolete solar forcing curve means that all other detection and attribution work is wrong. From this "evidence", they then claim that all variations in climate are internal variability, except for the warming trend which is caused by the sun, oh and by the way the globe is cooling.

Devastating eh?

One can see a number of basic flaws here; the complete lack of appreciation of the importance of natural variability on short time scales, the common but erroneous belief that any attribution of past climate change to solar or other forcing means that CO2 has no radiative effect, and a hopeless lack of familiarity of the basic science of detection and attribution.

But it gets worse, what solid peer reviewed science do they cite for support? A heavily-criticised blog posting..."
There's more there. Read it if you have the fortitude. (Propagandists never do, though.)

Screw it. You're obviously too embedded in your screwed up fantasy of ultra-conservative politics. Since you are too lazy to do any of your own research, here's where your opinions were created FOR you:

http://www.uctv.tv/search-details.aspx?showID=13459

http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warming/science_and_impacts/global_warming_contrarians/exxonmobil-report-smoke.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/24/science/earth/24deny.html?_r=2

http://www.cbc.ca/fifth/denialmachine/video.html


I advocate EcoNuremberg for any and all that have lied, are lying, or will ever lie about the state of the environment, for they are killing us all. May you all rot in jail, or, better yet, be left to fend for yourselves with nothing but your limited wits where Climate Change hits hardest.

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

The Perfect Storm World Simulation: Peak Oil, Climate Change, Economic Collapse

Enough economics for awhile. All two of you, besides myself, that read this blog already know what I think on that. Other facets of The Perfect Storm need some attention. I'd like to look at the big picture with an eye toward solutions.

The problem is simple: Anthropogenically-forced Climate Change (ACC), Peak Oil (PO), economic collapse, etc., are in the early stages of potentially remaking our world in ways we really would like to avoid, but there is almost nothing being done about any of it in any real sense when you consider the massive changes that are needed to deal with all these problems. If you think a bit on how long it takes to change the way a few billion people live, it's clear we have nearly run out of time to find solutions and implement them.

Robert Hirsch, et al., determined in a study done in 2005 that mitigating PO with minimal effects would require starting twenty years before the peak. Starting ten years before would lead to serious issues, but could be done. Waiting until peak would result in serious problems. Peak appears to have come in 2008.

Oops.

Then there's ACC. A recent poll of climate scientists shows they are far more worried about ACC than is generally understood. But for James Hansen, they tend to be pretty quiet and conservative in their pronouncements on climate. This is (intellectually) understandable. They are scientists and are expected to state what they can prove, not what they know to be true. But aren't we past the point of this little luxury? Are not the dire consequences of no action or too little action being taken - a world 2 to 6C warmer - too great to risk? Well, finally some are speaking out... anonymously. (Way to put your necks out there, Profs!)

World will not meet 2C warming target, climate change experts agree

Guardian poll reveals almost nine out of 10 climate experts do not
believe current political efforts will keep warming below 2C

The poll of those who follow global warming most closely exposes a widening gulf between political rhetoric and scientific opinions on climate change.

While policymakers and campaigners focus on the 2C target, 86% of the experts told the survey they did not think it would be achieved.

...60% of respondents argued that, in theory, it was still technically and
economically possible to meet

...global warming of 2C

... But 39% said the 2C target was impossible.

...84 of the 182 specialists (46%) who answered the question said it would reach 3-4C by the end of the century; 47 (26%) suggested a rise of 2-3C, while a handful said 6C or more. While 24 experts predicted a catastrophic rise of 4-5C, just 18 thought it would stay at 2C or under.

Geewillickers... You gotta see some quotes from here:

Climate change experts reveal their hopes and fears

  • By 2100 I seriously fear there will be civilization collapse and chaos.
  • We should also be mindful that temperature sensitivity of the planet... has been grossly underestimated... We are in extremely dangerous territory.
  • Nothing short of a major restructuring of the energy generation system will see us limiting climate change to a 2C rise.

Now, don't you feel all warm and fuzzy? No? It gets worse.

To meet climate goal, cut fossil fuels use: study

The paper, published by the British journal Nature, implies only a revolution in energy use can achieve the aim of limiting warming to less than two degrees Celsius (3.8 degrees Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial levels.

To achieve the objective -- embraced by the European Union (EU) and many scientists -- means that only 1,000 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) can be emitted between 2000 and 2050, it said.

By comparison, the world has emitted a third of that amount in just nine years.

"If we continue burning fossil fuels as we do, we will have exhausted the carbon budget in merely 20 years, and global warming will go well beyond two degrees," said the study's lead author, Malte Meinshausen of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Berlin.

So, how much carbon have you cut out of your life today? None? Well! We're moving right along, aren't we! Look around you. Other than cuts caused by the recession, do you see people really changing how they use energy?

Paradoxically, PO will both helping us reduce our use of Fossil Fuels and make it harder to do so. To wit:

  1. Crude oil production likely peaked in 2008.
  2. On one hand, the use of oil will fall over the next few decades. On the other, if renewable forms of energy can't replace crude oil, then tar sands and coal will. Both are much greater emitters of CO2 than crude oil is.
  3. Having run out of hands, now use your feet to factor in the economic hit of declining oil production. (In both recessions in the '70's, the percentage drop in crude oil production and the drop in GDP were about the same, e.g.)
  4. As the "recession" begins to abate, the economic hit from PO will most likely stop it in its tracks.
  5. Investments for renewable energies will almost certainly be reduced by the economic crash.

To make matters ever-so-much better, what do Americans think about climate change? Not much.

Only 34% blame humans for global warming

Just one-out-of-three voters (34%) now believe global warming is caused by human activity, the lowest finding yet in Rasmussen Reports national surveying. However, a plurality (48%) of the Political Class believes humans are to blame.

Forty-eight percent (48%) of all likely voters attribute climate change to long-term planetary trends, while seven percent (7%) blame some other reason. Eleven percent (11%) aren’t sure.

These numbers reflect a reversal from a year ago when 47% blamed human activity while 34% said long-term planetary trends.

If you're feeling like kicking the dog or drinking your way through every bar between you and the Restaurant at the End of the Universe, hold on a second. I have a plan. Really.

Below is an e-mail (modified for this post) I sent not long ago to someone I thought, based on previous work, might be interested in modeling global solutions to The Perfect Storm. Sadly, no response. Maybe someone will stumble across it here and find a kernel of a good idea in it.

Dear X,
My wife and I have had an idea in our minds for quite some time for a massively interactive virtual reality world/MMPRPG/global climate model/global energy model/global economic model: The Perfect Storm World Simulation: Peak Oil, Climate Change, Economic Collapse.

The idea started from a simple question we, as teachers, asked ourselves: How could we do outreach on the issues of Climate Change, Peak Oil and the Economic Crash - what I call a Perfect Storm? (E.g. my blog is aperfectstormcometh.blogspot.com.) We needed something that would integrate everything we faced, but do it at the personal level and governmental level. We needed a synthesis of both to help get change going since government moves too slowly and grassroots movements alone are not going to manage the massive changes needed - though I think grassroots movements like Transition Towns, the Post-Carbon Institute and the Relocalization movement will be the primary players in the end since the changes start and end with what we do, what we buy, how we live day-to-day.

The answer was an on-line game. Rather, a live modeling project that would both inform people (nearly half of all Americans still have significant doubts about Climate Change and far less know about Peak Oil) about the issues and help find a collaborative solution.From there we brainstormed and by the time we were done had an idea that was so massively beyond our skill sets we knew we were hopelessly over matched. We envisioned something with the following components or characteristics:

- It would be huge, along the lines of MMPRPGs, but necessarily bigger than any before it. This needs to be international in scope since any solutions must also be, and must offer realistic simulations.

- It would include participation of individuals from all levels of society, i.e., gov't. officials and orgs, non-profits, NGO's and, most importantly, the public.

- It would preferably have an interface like virtual reality game.

- It would have real climate models attached, or at least data from models as part of the data so people can see climate effects of their own actions as they happen in the game.

- It would would include energy decline reality.

- It would include other resource constraints (water, fisheries, farming, etc.)

- It would include real-world economic data.

- It would allow for new models of governance, economic systems and societal structures to be tried and tested, such as Steady State economic models (1, 2, 3), barter economies, etc.

- Perhaps multiple runs/games going simultaneously, much like Global Climate Models. Maybe individuals could start up their own runs and people could jump in if they liked the parameters set by the originator?

- Perhaps dummy nodes/agents coded to model the averages for given regions/cities/countries to get the numbers up as high as possible.

Etc.

I started research on what was already out there. The RPG idea was clear enough. Such things as The Sims, SecondLife, World Without Oil, etc., already exist.

My research found possible components for other elements. Purdue University has SEAS. It has been used for gov't simulations before. The software team codes a scenario and real people are agents in the game. There are other nodes (agents) that are run as part of the model and represent people. It's been used for some disaster planning, etc. The goal, of course, is to have millions of real people actually acting in the simulations. They may already have that, but my impression is that only gov't officials and first responders actually participate. It might be a good foundation for the basic structure - or not. I *believe* they have a virtual presentation like an MMPRPG.

A second is the T21 program out of the Millennium Institute.

T21-North America User Interface Released!
Arlington, VA, October 18, 2007

The T21-North America (T21-NA) model user interface was released today. The user interface allows the model to be open, modified and simulated on any Windows-based computer.

The T21-NA model project is a collaboration with Association for the Study of Peak Oil and Gas-USA and State University of New York’s College of Environmental Science and Forestry to examine energy issues in the context of an integrated framework that incorporates the relations of the energy sector to the broader economic, social, and environmental framework. The project is part of ASPO-USA’s Global Energy Modeling project.

Their software is a package run by programmers, so far as I can tell. That is, it is not an MMPRPG-, SEAS- or Alternate Reality-style package that real people are involved in; it's based on a few people inputting what they think is important rather than real people acting as they, hopefully, would in reality. I think.

A third choice might be the World3 program used by for Limits to Growth. Delores Garcia is developing/has developed an updated version of this program:

Abstract: An updated systems model of global climate, resources, and energy extending the original World3 (“Limits to Growth”) model by inclusion of climate change and it's interaction with resources and energy. Outcomes are derived for total energy resources, human population, nutrition, consumption, economic activity and other parameters. Long-term outcomes are derived for a 1900 C.E. to 2100 C.E. time sequence, with human population decline.

The weakness here is, of course, that it is not a live simulation, but a model dependent solely on inputs from the programmer. It does, however, represent a good bit of the breadth we need as it includes energy, food production, climate, etc., as noted above, and may be the closest of the three to what we are thinking of.

It may well be that something this complex and wide-ranging needs to be built from scratch. Having worked in the documentation department of a main frame software company, I can appreciate the difficulties encountered trying to integrate software not designed to work together.

As for implementation, I'd be hoping to have this made available world-wide for free so there are no restrictions. Ideally, we'd capture the imagination of some important people and be able to make a big deal of the launch and subsequent modeling with an eye toward 1. raising awareness of how serious the times are and 2. actually modelling a solution or two that might be viable, or at least move us towards some solutions.

This approach also, and perhaps most importantly, takes the policy, research and data input out from behind the closed doors and gilt halls of TPTB and gets them into the hands of the public at large.

Time is short. People need to wake up to the serious problems we face and we need a workable solution yesterday. I believe The Perfect Storm World Simulation: Peak Oil, Climate Change, Economic Collapse can both raise awareness and model possible solution scenarios.

Cheers

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Of Crashes, Failures and Bailouts - Round V: Blacker Than Ever

THIS POST IS no longer IN PROGRESS. LAST UPDATE AT 1:31 PM EDT 4/15/09

The following is excerpted from an interview in Barron's (click the title to go to the original) of William Black by Jack Willoughby. What Black says isn't so amazing. Others have said it, and far earlier. I have previously posted comments and links to The Automatic Earth (which is where I found the original article from Barron's), Karl Denninger, Peter Schiff and others saying essentially all the same things. It's that he's the one saying it. William Black has gravitas. He has the pedigree. Those who would dismiss, and have dismissed, the voices in the wilderness noted above, can't so easily do the same to William Black.

There's not really anything new here that wasn't in Of Crashes, Failures and Bailouts - Round IV, but it's all worth repeating just for emphasis.

My comments below the interview.

Barron's: Just how serious is this credit crisis? What is at stake here for the American taxpayer?

Black: ...The scale of fraud is immense...

So you are saying Democrats as well as Republicans share the blame? No one can claim the high ground?

We have failed bankers giving advice to failed regulators on how to deal with failed assets. How can it result in anything but failure? ...Tim Geithner, the current Secretary of the Treasury, and Larry Summers, chairman of the National Economic Council, were important architects of the problems...

So you aren't a fan of the recently announced plan for the government to back private purchases of the toxic assets?

It is worse than a lie. Geithner... is really pandering to the interests of a select group of banks who are on a first-name basis with Washington politicians. The current law mandates prompt corrective action, which means speedy resolution of insolvencies. He is flouting the law, in naked violation, in order to pursue the kind of favoritism that the law was designed to prevent...

...It is like Gresham's law: Bad money drives out the good. Well, bad behavior drives out good behavior, without good enforcement.

...By promoting this notion of too-big-to-fail, we are allowing a pernicious influence to remain in Washington...

Summarize the problem as best you can for Barron's readers.

With most of America's biggest banks insolvent, you have, in essence, a multitrillion dollar cover-up by publicly traded entities, which amounts to felony securities fraud on a massive scale.

These firms will ultimately have to be forced into receivership, the management and boards stripped of office, title, and compensation. First... a Pecora-style fact-finding mission conducted without fear or favor... Then... pursue criminal cases...

What, then, is staying the federal government's hand? Have the banks become too difficult or complex to regulate?

...to do so would force it to put some of America's biggest financial institutions into receivership... these banks are some of the most well-connected in Washington...

Can you explain your idea of control fraud, and how it applies to the current banking and the earlier thrift crisis?

Control fraud is when a seemingly legitimate corporation uses its power as a weapon to defraud or take something of value through deceit.

...These accounting frauds create huge bubbles...

Why then is there so much smoke and so little action?

...The reason we don't see it -- aren't told about it -- is that if they were honest, prompt corrective action would kick in...

You say the evidence of a breakdown in the regulatory structure comes from the fact that America avoided an earlier subprime crisis in the 1990s.

Exactly. Why had no one heard of the subprime crisis back in 1991? Because America's regulators also faced down the crisis early... the problem didn't spread -- because regulators intervened.

What needs to be done?

Well, these international behemoths need to be broken down into smaller units... And a new seriousness must be put into regulation... We just need folks who can enforce the ones already on the books.

The bank-compensation system also creates an environment that leads to mismanagement and fraud... the top 20% get the bulk of the benefits and the bottom 10% get fired... Compensation systems... discourage whistleblowing -- the most common way that frauds are found in America -- because the system draws upon the cooperation of everyone.

This whole thing isn't over. Those in government or the financial industry saying we are past the bottom and will be coming out of recession within months, or maybe the end of the year, are liars or fools. The proof is in the pudding.

Question: How can the recession end when loan defaults - of all kinds and all sectors of the economy - are still raging? Take a look at this Mortgage Reset Chart. We are currently at a lull in resets. They surge again through 2010-2011.

Which brings us to inventory. John Mauldin at Minyanville observes:

No Housing Recovery Lurks in Shadow Inventory
- The Shadow Inventory of Homes

...a strange thing is happening: We're seeing what's being called a "shadow inventory" of foreclosed homes.

The San Francisco Chronicle reports:"We believe there are in the neighborhood of 600,000 properties nationwide that banks have repossessed but not put on the market," said Rick Sharga, vice president of RealtyTrac...

A RealtyTrac survey found that only 30% of foreclosures were listed for sale in real-estate listings, like the MLS (Multiple Listing Service). Add in homes that people would like to sell but simply can't find buyers for and must either hold or rent, and the unsold inventory numbers that are public are likely far below actual available homes.

Might some homes in foreclosure be held off the market because banks eventually want to negotiate with the homeowner? Possibly. But other surveys show that anywhere from 30%-40% of homes in the foreclosure process in many areas are actually already vacant. There's no one with whom to negotiate...

...Normally there are about 160,000 homes a year in foreclosure sales. We're now seeing 80,000 a month, or 6 times normal levels, and rising.

Second, lenders could be deferring sales to put off having to acknowledge the actual extent of their losses. "With banks in the stress they're in, I don't think they're anxious to show losses in assets on their balance sheets," one observer said.

Finally, banks may not want to flood the market with foreclosures, driving prices down even more...

But it gets worse.

And it does. He goes on to list some of the things I'm already writing here, and more. You should read the article.

And what about commercial real estate? Prices are crashing and defaults rising as we speak. Credit card debt? Credit lines are being canceled or slashed as banks look to control losses or costs. Being a good risk is now a liability: they earn no interest and/or fees from you if you don't carry a balance, yet have money out to you. Liquidity is at issue. Every bank and financial entity wants cash. They need cash. You lose.

More importantly, as Meredith Whitney has pointed out, credit cards and credit lines have been what enabled many families the flexibility to manage tricky finances. As more restrictions are placed on personal credit, the more families that will be forced into default.

Few doubt the importance of consumer spending to the U.S. economy and its multiplier effect on the global economy, but what is underappreciated is the role of credit-card availability in that spending. Currently, there is roughly $5 trillion in credit-card lines outstanding in the U.S., and a little more than $800 billion is currently drawn upon. While those numbers look small relative to total mortgage debt of over $10.5 trillion, credit-card debt is revolving and accordingly being paid off and drawn down over and over, creating a critical role in commerce in America.

Just six months ago, I estimated that at least $2 trillion of available credit-card lines would be expunged from the system by the end of 2010. However, today, that estimate now looks optimistic, as available lines were reduced by nearly $500 billion in the fourth quarter of 2008 alone. My revised estimates are that over $2 trillion of credit-card lines will be cut inside of 2009, and $2.7 trillion by the end of 2010.

Where is the recovery?

Global trade is still falling as can be seen in import and export numbers around the globe, which also reflects in shipping. Manufacturing - JOBS - will continue to fall in lockstep. Unemployment continues to rise even as extended benefits are running out for those early in the unemployment line. Real unemployment is now just below 20%.

Where is the recovery?

The financial sector is insolvent, but won't admit it. Housing and commercial real estate are so overbuilt squatters are taking over homes everywhere. Where the hell is the recovery supposed to come from? Foreign companies? Foreign countries? The U.S. is the consumption engine of the world. It is 20% or more of the global economy and 70% of that is consumerism. Service industries. In other words, pointless, useless and producing almost zero infrastructure/real capital. Do the math. That's 14% of the global economy that is kitsch and junk. Price/Earnings ratios are shot.

Et-flippin'-cetera.

Where is the recovery?

I call this blog A Perfect Storm Cometh. The financial unwind is only one part. Let's say we do go into recovery within the next six-to-eight months. Growth takes energy. Cheap energy. The densest energy we currently can tap cheaply and easily is oil. However, oil production is falling due to both above ground (non-geological) and below ground (geological) reasons.

The natural decline rate of crude oil production is at over 9% per year. That's over 6.5 million barrels a day. New production each year brings that number down to 6+% or 4.5 to 5 million barrels a day lost each year. Let's put that in perspective. That's a full Saudi Arabia every two years. We aren't finding anywhere near that much oil and haven't for decades. For now, the drop in production because of recession is masking the drop in production due to Peak Oil. Keeping this in mind, the recession **helps** with Peak Oil in the immediate future, but not in the longer term.

The problem is that the recession is not only reducing oil consumption, thus production, as a result of lowered demand, it is cutting future production. New wells aren't being drilled as fast. Old wells aren't being improved with technology. Expensive wells are being shut down while waiting for higher prices. IF a recovery started, it would run into the brick wall of slow-to-recover production and decline. The longer the recession (PC talk for depression, it seems) goes on, the more likely no new peak in production can be hit. The reason is simple: we have produced about half of all oil we can reasonably get to for reasonable prices. The rest is in smaller fields that are harder to reach. Consider my modified haystack analogy.

Imagine a giant haystack. Rather than the proverbial needle, in the hay are ten basketballs, 100 tennis balls and 1000 marbles. (Imagine our magic haystack keeps all objects suspended so they don't all fall to the floor.) The result?

  • We will absolutely find all of the ten basketballs before we find all 100 tennis balls. Or even a majority.
  • We will absolutely find all the tennis balls before we find all the marbles.
  • We will find some of each from the very start.
  • We will find all the basketballs in the early part of our search, say the first 25 - 40% of total time spent looking.
  • The basketballs will equal a majority of all balls/marbles by volume.
    (Take a look at the Discovery/Production graph at the bottom of the blog.)

We've already found all the basketballs and a bunch of the tennis balls. We're down a few tennis balls and a bunch of marbles. Regarding production, the basketballs are going seriously flat and a bunch of tennis balls are getting flat or are empty. There's a lot of oil, but it's just not going to be possible to increase how fast we can get at it.

Where is the recovery?

Economic impacts? In the two large recessions of the 70's, GDP and oil production reflected one another, falling by similar percentages. In historical terms economic growth, food production and population have all tracked along with oil production. Both GDP and oil production are falling at this time. Again, by similar amounts. (See graphs at the bottom of this blog.)

The historic interplay of oil and economy is also seen in oil prices and recessions. Check out the graph at the beginning of the post below.

Oil Addiction and Recession

Vulnerability to oil prices helped cause this collapse

Poorly regulated real-estate lending wasn’t the only cause of the economic meltdown now gripping the industrial economies. Oil addiction also contributed.

The extraordinary rise in oil prices since 2003 has sucked hundreds of billions of dollars out of the US economy (and the Cascadian economy).High oil prices have been a contributing cause of most recessions: Since 1948, “all large oil price increases but two have been followed by recessions,” as Andrew Hoerner and Nia Robinson of Redefining Progress (RP) write (pdf). “Four of the five recessions since 1970 . . . were preceded by big jumps in oil prices.”

Oil prices are now down 4 - 6%. Fourth quarter '08 GDP was falling at an annual rate of around 6%. Coincidence? These two posts discuss the connections between oil prices and the economy.

The oil shock and recession of 2008: Part 1
The oil shock and recession of 2008: Part 2

When, not if (barring a Dark Ages-level global collapse), production declines overtake falling demand, the prices will rocket upward. Again. Price volatility should be the norm, as it has been, now and in the future.

Where is the recovery?

The third part of the Perfect Storm is Anthropogenically-driven Climate Change (ACC.).

Without going into it too far, all of the above have a negative impact on ACC. Obviously, economic limits will affect the building of "green" infrastructure as credit is tight and resources are dwindling. It is important that governments understand that the long term health and safety of their nation and people depends on not losing sight of what happens if we don't successfully transition to sustainable energies and sustainable societies.

It has been reported that climate scientists are privately far more pessimistic about the future than they are letting on. Public pronouncements parrot the 2C warming locked in even if we successfully manage Green House Gas (GHG) emissions this century. Privately, there is talk that 3C or 4C is more likely. This is very bad news, of course, which illustrates that action can't wait, but with the economy crashing and energy decline likely to keep it crashing for the next 5 to 10 years (if renewables don't ramp up, it could last decades), how are we supposed to manage the transition to a low- or no-carbon society?

The answers might be simpler - though not necessarily easy - than one might think: Just say no.

More on that later.

Cheers